I cannot recall a single issue within the American Jewish community that has
been more divisive than the nuclear agreement negotiated with Iran this past
July. As I shared a few weeks ago, advocacy groups such as the American Israel
Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) as well as J Street have been lobbying hard to
persuade members of Congress either to vote in favor or in opposition of the
I have been a member of the Central Conference of American Rabbis since my
ordination over three decades ago. The CCAR has on many occasions taken
very public stances advocating particular positions. However, on this specific
issue of the Iran nuclear agreement, the CCAR leadership, recognizing the
passionate positions taken on both sides of the issue by its member, decided that
as a body, the CCAR could not take a position since there is no broad based
consensus within our organization.
Nonetheless, this does not preclude each rabbi choosing to express his or her
own perspective. I have chosen to do so when some weeks ago I was
approached by a respected senior colleague to sign my name to a document
addressed to members of Congress created by Ameinu. “Ameinu, Hebrew for
‘Our People,’ is a national, multi-generational community of progressive Jews in
North America. “
I read the letter carefully, and though I did not completely concur with every
single word, I overwhelmingly agreed with its major points. I believe that the
nuclear agreement with Iran is of paramount importance for our country, for
Israel, and for the world. To remain silent on this issue would be for me a
grievous act of cowardice.
I chose to add my name as an endorser of the letter to Congress without having
any idea how many other rabbis had signed on. To me, the issue of numbers of
endorsees was irrelevant. It is a matter of principle whether you agree or not
with the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA). Hewing to principles is
not about winning popularity contests.
Lastly, as a signatory of the Ameinu statement, I, along with the other signatories
are identified by the city in which we reside, but not by the congregations we
lead. I think that’s a significant point. On the one hand, I serve as rabbi of this
congregation. However, there has been no communal dialogue about this topic
at Temple Beth Torah – no educational seminar, no discussion by the board, no
consideration by a representative group of our congregation. To that end,
therefore, as a signatory of the Ameinu statement I am expressing my personal
perspective and not a communal one. The difference may seem slight, but it’s
At last count, over 340 rabbis from all Jewish dominations have signed-on to this
statement. Below is the text of the document.
As always, you are invited to disagree or agree with my perspective. I always
welcome dialogue with members of our congregational community.
August 17, 2015
Members of the U.S. House of Representatives
Members of the U.S. Senate
As rabbis, we support the agreement between the United States, the United
Kingdom, France, Germany, China, Russia and Iran– The Joint Comprehensive
Plan of Action. We encourage the members of the Senate and the House of
Representatives to endorse this agreement.
The Obama administration has successfully brought together the major
international powers to confront Iran over its nuclear ambitions. The broad
international sanctions moved Iran to enter this historic agreement. Should this
agreement be rejected by the U.S. Congress, those sanctions will end. There will
be no new negotiations, as the other member countries are fully in favor of this
agreement and have no desire to re-negotiate.
We understand that while this agreement blocks Iran’s path to a nuclear bomb,
we recognize it does not deal with Iran’s support for terror, but that was never the
purpose of these talks. Now that a nuclear agreement has been reached, we call
on the United States and its international partners to strengthen their resolve and
dedicate additional resources to confront Iranian threats to Israel and other
Most especially, we are deeply concerned with the impression that the leadership
of the American Jewish community is united in opposition to the agreement. We,
along with many other Jewish leaders, fully support this historic nuclear accord.
See more at: http://www.ameinu.net/newsroom/press-release/340-rabbis-urge-